Pippin, I would love to have a little pow-wow or something about this. It has absolutely stumped me. Since WP 3.5, this has been happening on many people’s servers for any instance of paginated elements in the theme where I use query_posts, whether there is a
wp_reset_query() after query_posts or not. Weird thing is if you have some sort of widget or whatever that uses the deprecated “showposts” it will override and work.
This is searchable archive of our old support forums, which operated from 2012 - 2016. To find out how to get support for your current theme, please visit our support page.